‘Barbarian’ Film Theories: Explanations, Themes, and Meaning

The first thing I noticed (and loved) about Barbarian (2022) was the broad, almost allegorical references to the classic novel Jane Eyre. If you didn’t catch that the first time around, I recommend a rewatch of this excellent horror film.

But before you hit play, check out my Barbarian analysis below, complete with theories, themes, and my own personal thoughts.

Screenshot from “Barbarian” trailer.

Top Theories About the Meaning and Themes of ‘Barbarian’ (2022)

1. Thematic Horror of Patriarchy and Abuse

Theory: Barbarian is an allegory for the generational cycles of abuse perpetuated by men and the ways in which society ignores or enables these horrors.

• Why It Fits:
  • The film presents different types of male predators—Frank, a violent abductor and rapist; AJ, an entitled man who refuses to take responsibility for his assault; and even Keith, whose initial kindness is suspicious due to Tess’s learned wariness of men. Tess’s struggle represents the larger struggle of women navigating a world where danger is always lurking, yet often dismissed.
• Key Moments:
  • The revelation of Frank’s tapes and his legacy of predation.
  • AJ refusing to acknowledge his crime, instead worrying about his reputation.
  • The police officers dismissing Tess despite her clear distress.
  • The final moment where Tess is forced to kill The Mother—a product of male violence.

2. Gentrification as a Modern Horror

Theory: The film critiques the consequences of urban decay and gentrification, showing how economic and social neglect create hidden horrors beneath the surface.

• Why It Fits:
  • The neighborhood is visibly abandoned and ignored, highlighting Detroit’s real-life economic collapse. The house looks safe at first, but beneath it lies the horrific consequences of decades of societal neglect. AJ, a Hollywood figure with no real connection to the community, arrives thinking only about profit, oblivious to the deep suffering hidden within the property.
• Key Moments:
  • The stark contrast between the Airbnb’s cozy interior and the surrounding ruins.
  • Andre’s warning that The Mother is not the true monster—Frank is, representing deeper, systemic horrors.
  • AJ viewing the underground tunnels as potential added square footage rather than a horrifying dungeon.

3. The Mother as a Tragic Victim

Theory: The Mother is not a monster but a tragic, tortured figure—a result of extreme abuse and neglect rather than inherent evil.

• Why It Fits:
  • While The Mother is terrifying, her actions stem from a warped maternal instinct rather than malice. She sees Tess and AJ as her “children” and simply wants to care for them in the only way she knows. Her final act of self-sacrifice for Tess further humanizes her, making it clear that she is as much a victim as anyone else.
• Key Moments:
  • The Mother nursing AJ instead of killing him outright.
  • The flashback revealing her origins—she was born into a nightmare and knows nothing else.
  • Her decision to jump off the tower to save Tess rather than let her die.

4. Toxic Masculinity and Different Shades of Male Villainy

Theory: The film showcases various forms of toxic masculinity, from outright evil to casual selfishness, demonstrating how men’s actions shape the world women are forced to survive in.

• Why It Fits:
  • Frank represents the worst of the worst—a serial predator whose unchecked violence created a living horror. AJ represents the more common but insidious form of toxic masculinity—entitlement, denial, and cowardice. Keith, while seemingly good, still places Tess in an uncomfortable position by insisting she stay in the house rather than leaving himself.
• Key Moments:
  • AJ rationalizing his assault, refusing to acknowledge his role.
  • Keith being well-intentioned but still controlling the situation rather than letting Tess make her own choices.
  • AJ pushing Tess off the tower, sacrificing her to save himself.

5. The Dangers of Ignoring Warnings

Theory: Barbarian is a classic horror fable about ignoring clear warning signs and suffering the consequences.

• Why It Fits:
  • Nearly every bad event in the film could have been avoided had characters heeded warnings—Tess ignoring the warnings about the neighborhood, Keith ignoring Tess’s warning about the tunnel, AJ ignoring the deeper implications of the basement, and the police ignoring Tess entirely. This reflects a larger horror trope: society ignores clear danger until it’s too late.
• Key Moments:
  • The homeless man trying to warn Tess, only for her to run from him instead.
  • The police refusing to believe Tess because she doesn’t look like a “credible” victim.
  • Keith dismissing Tess’s instincts, leading to his death.

Key Themes in ‘Barbarian’

The Fear of the Unknown

The film plays on the primal fear of what lurks beneath the surface—both literally and figuratively. The hidden tunnels beneath the house represent the unseen horrors of the past, while the unknown intentions of strangers like Keith and AJ keep the audience in suspense.

Society’s Failure to Protect the Vulnerable

Throughout the film, institutions and individuals fail to help those in need. The police dismiss Tess’s pleas, the city has abandoned the neighborhood, and Frank was able to operate for decades without consequence. This theme highlights how victims—especially women—are often left to fend for themselves.

Survival Instinct vs. Morality

Tess repeatedly makes choices that prioritize helping others over her own survival, while AJ does the opposite. The film explores how individuals react under extreme pressure—whether they act selfishly, morally, or somewhere in between.

The Weight of the Past

The house itself is a metaphor for the lingering effects of past sins. Frank’s actions have tainted the home, and even though it appears modern and inviting on the surface (as an Airbnb), its foundation is rotted with violence and trauma. The film suggests that the past cannot be buried—it will always resurface.

Motherhood as Horror and Nurture

The Mother is both terrifying and tragically nurturing. Her desire to care for Tess and AJ is rooted in something primal, yet her methods are horrific due to the circumstances of her own upbringing. The film blurs the line between monstrous motherhood and the deep biological need to protect.

Plot Summary

• Year Released: 2022
• Director: Zach Cregger
• Writer: Zach Cregger

Tess arrives at an Airbnb in a decayed Detroit neighborhood, only to find it double-booked by a man named Keith. Despite initial unease, she stays. After a series of unsettling events, she discovers a hidden basement with disturbing evidence of past horrors. Keith is violently killed by a monstrous woman known as The Mother.

AJ, the house’s owner and an actor accused of sexual assault, arrives to assess the property. He unknowingly ventures into the underground tunnels and is captured by The Mother, who treats him and Tess as her “children.” A flashback reveals that Frank, the original owner, abducted and assaulted women for decades, creating generations of inbred offspring.

Tess escapes but is ignored by police. She returns to help AJ, who ultimately sacrifices her to save himself. The Mother, however, protects Tess, killing AJ before being shot by Tess in a final act of mercy. The film ends at sunrise, as Tess limps away from the house’s long-buried horrors.

Movies with Similar Themes to ‘Barbarian’

(*This site is reader-supported. If you buy something through the links below, I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases made through these links.)

The Texas Chain Saw Massacre (1974)

A group of travelers stumbles upon a remote house harboring a family of cannibalistic killers. Like Barbarian, it explores the horrors of isolation, hidden family secrets, and the monstrous consequences of unchecked brutality.

—> Watch The Texas Chain Saw Massacre online.

Don’t Breathe (2016)

A group of young thieves breaks into a blind man’s house, only to discover he harbors dark and violent secrets. Both films subvert expectations about who the real monster is and feature hidden horrors lurking beneath a seemingly ordinary home.

—> Watch Don’t Breathe online.

The Descent (2005)

A group of women explores an uncharted cave system, only to become trapped and hunted by terrifying creatures. The film shares Barbarian’s claustrophobic horror and themes of survival against an unknown subterranean threat.

—> Watch The Descent online.

House of 1000 Corpses (2003)

Travelers fall victim to a sadistic family with a history of kidnapping and torture. Like Barbarian, it examines generational horror, grotesque family legacies, and the thin line between human and monster.

—> Watch House of 1000 Corpses online.

It Follows (2014)

A young woman is stalked by a supernatural entity after a sexual encounter, mirroring Barbarian’s themes of predation, unseen danger, and societal indifference to victims.

—> Watch It Follows online.

Creep (2014)

A man answers a job listing to film a supposedly dying stranger’s final messages but slowly realizes he’s being lured into something sinister. Both films build tension through psychological manipulation and the fear of trusting strangers.

—> Watch Creep online.

The People Under the Stairs (1991)

A young boy breaks into a wealthy couple’s home and finds captives hidden in the basement. It shares Barbarian’s themes of urban decay, predatory figures, and the horrors lurking beneath a seemingly normal house.

—> Watch The People Under the Stairs online.

X (2022)

A group filming an adult movie on a rural farm becomes the target of a violent, repressed older couple. Like Barbarian, it explores themes of sexual repression, hidden dangers, and monstrous maternal figures.

—> Watch X online.

Have Your Own ‘Barbarian’ Theory?

As an avid reader of all the horror movie subreddits, I noticed that Barbarian seems to have split horror audiences down the middle — some love it, some hate it.

Where do you fall on that spectrum? And do you have any thoughts on this film I haven’t covered here? I’d love to hear them.

😱